AdvertiseDonate
Latest13-Year-Old Boy Shot Dead Near School in East Jerusalem Shuafat
Sat, Nov 21, 2026PlanoMcKinneyPhoenixPhiladelphiaJacksonvilleColumbusWashingtonEl Paso
Hot Report Now · 700 Central Expy S, Suite 400, Allen, TX 75013
News · Charlotte

Florida Man Faces Murder Trial for Killing Woman Met on Defunct Porn Site

Dwain Hall, 54, is on trial in Gainesville, accused of kidnapping and killing Sonia Exelby after grooming her on Motherless.com.

By David Mokoena ·

Illustration for: Florida Man Faces Murder Trial for Killing Woman Met on Defunct Porn Site
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Dwain Hall, a 54-year-old Florida man, is standing trial in Marion County on charges of first-degree murder and kidnapping. Prosecutors allege he killed Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music tutor from southern England, in October 2025. Hall, who used the online alias Alpha Sadist, met Exelby on Motherless.com, an extreme pornography platform that is now offline. He has pleaded not guilty to both counts.

The prosecution argues that Hall exploited Exelby’s mental health struggles to groom her over a two-year period. Assistant State Attorney Amy Berndt told the court that Exelby suffered from severe depression and suicidal ideation, having previously attempted suicide twice. Berndt stated that Exelby sought a substitute for self-harm and communicated with multiple men on the site who expressed willingness to kill her. “Sonia was communicating on Motherless with many different men. She was trying to find somebody that would kill her,” Berndt said.

Prosecutors say Hall demanded $4,000 in cash from Exelby in exchange for ending her life. The defense maintains that Hall was assisting a woman who wanted to die. Hall admitted to police that he was intimate with Exelby but denies being the killer. The jury examined financial records, digital files, and physical evidence linking Hall to the crime scene.

Exelby traveled to the United States in October 2025 and was picked up by Hall at Gainesville Regional Airport. Prosecutors presented a text message Exelby allegedly sent to a friend, in which she wrote that Hall kept her phone and made it clear there was no escape unless she shot him. The message indicated she believed he would kill her quickly. Investigators recovered her body from a shallow grave on October 17, 2025, after Interpol alerted local police that she was missing in Britain.

Forensic analysis revealed four stab wounds and bruising on Exelby’s body. A knife used in the attack tested positive for her blood, and a shovel purchased for the burial was presented as evidence. Jurors viewed video from Hall’s phone in which he ordered Exelby to repeat that she wanted to be beaten and suffer. “This is how you wanted to die, right?” Hall asked in the footage. Investigators also found images of other women being raped and tortured on his mobile device.

Exelby’s sister, Sara, testified about Sonia’s difficult childhood and kind nature. Sara described her sister as someone who felt like a burden but remained supportive of others. “She felt she was a burden, which she absolutely wasn’t, but she just had such a beautiful nature,” Sara said. The trial began on Tuesday and is expected to continue for at least one week.

Motherless.com was taken offline in May by Dutch authorities after drawing international attention for hosting graphic content. In July, Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured a legal victory that cut off the site’s ability to operate under the .com registry. The case highlights concerns regarding technology-facilitated violence against women and the role of online platforms in such incidents.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Hot Report Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Hot Report Now in your inboxNews from America’s biggest cities. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.